It is now commonplace to see iPads and other tablets being used for navigation, but there is still quite a difference between the best and worst apps you can download. Pip Hare tests and compares seven popular apps for ipad and android.

The development of navigation apps has now advanced to the stage where tablets are being used regularly by many sailors as a primary means of navigation on board. With the recent integration of wi-fi NMEA data to the mix, tablet navigation systems have found a permanent place in our arsenal of instruments.

I have selected a mix of seven navigation apps specifically focussing on new updates and innovative developments, but also with my eye on what our basic requirements for a good navigational app should be. Tests were carried out inshore, offshore, creek hopping, racing and just sitting at home on my sofa using an iPad 2 and an ASUS model P023 running Android 5.0.2.

Top rated iPad navigation apps – read individual reviews below

The perfect iPad navigation app doesn’t yet exist but…

Having spent six weeks living and breathing these apps, I have come to the conclusion that the perfect one does not exist, but some are getting pretty close. The well-developed user interfaces that app-based products provide are far superior to those found on most chartplotters and now, with NMEA integration, the all-important GPS fix comes from an external feed overcoming any accuracy concerns around using the GPS receiver built in to the tablet.

To make the most of your chosen software, pick features that are relevant to your style of sailing. Think about what information you want displayed for easy situational awareness and make sure you spend time customising your display to show only what you need and, ideally, nothing more.

Crowd-sourced data

Crowd sourcing information has enabled the boating community to share local knowledge and update navigational features in real-time. Most apps now incorporate this in some way. A few apps are offering sonar mapping but Navionics also gives free access to its HD bathymetry Sonar Chart. This extra chart reveals more contours derived from a large database of sonar logs, which in many areas could provide more accurate charting than UKHO data.

Other crowd-sourced information includes the community edits, and the ‘Active Captain’ network, which is like an online almanac. If using this type of information for navigation check the date of the edit and treat new position info cautiously.

Top tips for setting up and using your iPad navigation device

Ports of refuge

Before setting off on longer passages ensure that you have downloaded the charts for any ports of refuge along the way and that your current package covers countries where you may conceivably need to make landfall.

Satellite image layers

Use satellite image layers, if available, to identify landmarks when approaching a new destination.

Check units: Lat and Long

Check your units when setting up an app. To help with easy communication of waypoints between charts, plotters and tablets ensure your position is reported in degrees, minutes and decimals. Many apps only use degrees and decimals to report positions, which could be confusing, particularly in an emergency situation.

Range rings

Set up range rings to use as clearing zones on navigational hazards, or even to indicate the three-boat-length zone around a mark when racing.

Velocity vector

The velocity vector shows you where you will end up after a specified amount of time. Set the value of this vector to one hour for help in predicting tidal offsets.

Chart updates

Check whether your chosen app includes chart updates and how they are accessed – many apps require a subscription after the first year to keep charts up to date.

This article updates the iPad navigation test from 2015. The links below are to the 2015 reviews that were not updated in the 2017 test

Imray iPad app –  Imray cartography • raster scanned charts • app free. Charts £29.99

Plan2Nav – Jeppesen C Map • C Map cartography • vector charts • app free. Charts £26.99

Memory Map – raster scanned charts • app free. Charts £25 UK and Ireland

See our Top Tips for using an iPad for navigation apps

 

  • Dirk

    This is an incomplete comparison and test. Navionics app now supports GPS wifi input from your boat instruments,depth and RMC (position, SOG/COG) sentence. But no AIS, as an example. INavx accepts almost all nmea0183 sentences. This makes a difference in navigating and recognizing potential collisions.

  • Richard Harris

    I am disappointed that this is largely a repeat of the review in YW in May 2013 apart from the addition of iSailor. Over the last year I have sailed over 6,000 miles with my IPAD and have found it a superb supplement to my handheld standby GPS largely replacing my PC in this function. (Try using a cockpit mounted plotter in heavy rain or thick fog!) Not mentioned in the review is the MaxSea Time Zero raster chart navigation App which I consider to be one of the best navigation Apps, raster or vector. It has very good scrolling and zooming, has good route making and route following capabilities, and provides user selectable information displays for COG, SOG, CTS, boat position, and many others. It also displays tidal flows and tidal heights. Its main drawback, which it shares with several others, is its poor chart updating provision. Also whilst it has route importing and exporting functionality, like most other navigation Apps this is fraught with difficulty because the manufacturers typically use different route and way-point data standards. This makes it difficult to use the information in other manufactures equipment! Given the trust we now put in electronic navigation and lack of any performance standards, is it time for publishers such as YW to help establish benchmarks that will allow performance to be more effectively measured and so encourage improvements in equipment performance?

  • ThinkActive

    An iPad 2?? – excuse me but hasn’t this device been obsolete for some considerable time now?

    The processing power and speed of the Air – and now Air 2 – are massively greater than the 2 (let alone the iPads 3/4).

  • Simply get an external GPS module for your WiFi-only iPad, e.g. Bad Elf GPS Pro, Dual XGPS150 or Garmin GLO. Or use a Bluetooth GPS receiver with a jailbroken iPad.

  • Courteaux

    “…can only base their position on triangulation from phone antennas…”
    You are wrong
    WiFi only iPads do not have any SIM inside, to be connected to the phone antennas. So you must have iPad with GPS included to use at sea far away from any WiFi or 3G remote antennas. This GPS is available only with devices using the option WiFi and 3G or 4G. No SIM card is required to get the GPS working.